Since both bicycles cost the same amount, Rs. 3500 each, the overall profit percentage on the pair is simply the average of the two individual profit percentages, without needing to weight one more than the other. If the required overall profit is 20% and the first bicycle was sold at 5% profit, then the second bicycle's profit percentage \( x \) must satisfy \[ \frac{5+x}{2}=20. \] Solving, \( 5+x=40 \), so \( x=35 \). Test each option against this average-based equation.
Because the two bicycles share the same cost price, their profit percentages average directly to the overall profit percentage, and only 35% on the second bicycle brings that average to the required 20%.
Therefore, the correct answer is 35%.