Step 1: Spot the right angle.
Since $PQ$ is tangent at $Q$, the radius $OQ$ meets it at $90^\circ$, so triangle $OQP$ is right angled at $Q$.
Step 2: Test the answer choices directly using Pythagoras instead of expanding algebra first.
We need $OP^2 = OQ^2 + PQ^2$, i.e. $(a+2)^2 = a^2 + 4b^2$. Try option (4), $b^2 = a+1$, meaning $4b^2 = 4a+4$.
Step 3: Check if it balances.
Right side becomes $a^2 + 4a + 4$, and left side $(a+2)^2 = a^2+4a+4$ too, so they match perfectly.
Step 4: Conclude.
Only option (4) satisfies the Pythagorean condition for every value of $a$.
\[ \boxed{b^2 = a+1} \]