Question:medium

A committee is to be formed from amongst 9 boys and 6 girls. In how many ways can the boys and girls divide themselves into groups of three so that no group has more than 2 girls and no group has all boys?

Updated On: Jan 13, 2026
  • \(15 (9!)\)
  • \(20 (9!)\)
  • \(45 (8!)\)
  • \(\frac{45}{2} (9!)\)
  • \(\frac{45}{2} (8!)\)
Show Solution

The Correct Option is D

Solution and Explanation

The correct answer is option (D):
\(\frac{45}{2} (9!)\)

Let's break down this combinatorial problem step by step to understand why the given answer is correct.

We have 9 boys and 6 girls, and we need to form groups of three. The constraints are:
1. No group can have more than 2 girls.
2. No group can have all boys (meaning at least one girl must be in a group, if any girl is present).

Since each group has three members, and no group can have more than two girls, the possible compositions of a group are:
* 2 girls, 1 boy
* 1 girl, 2 boys
* 0 girls, (all boys - This is restricted by the second condition) So we cannot have all 3 boys.

Let's consider how many groups are needed: Since we have 9 boys and 6 girls, and each group must consist of 3 members, a total of (9+6)/3 = 5 groups are needed.

Now, let's look at the possible compositions to satisfy the given constraints.

Since there are 6 girls, and we need to divide them into 5 groups, and a group can have at most 2 girls, there must be at least one group with two girls, because the average is 6 girls / 5 groups = 1.2 girls per group.

Let's deduce the compositions of groups, given the two constraints:

Possible cases:
* Case 1: 2 girls, 1 boy (1 group) + 1 girl, 2 boys (4 groups)
This would give us (2 girls+4*1 girl = 6 girls) and (1 boy+4*2 boys=9 boys).
* Case 2: 1 group 2 girls, 1 boy; 1 group 1 girl, 2 boys and 3 groups with 2 boys and 1 girl.
This also gives (2 girls + 1 girl + 3*1 girl = 6 girls) and (1 boy+2 boys + 3*2 boys = 9 boys).
* Case 3: It is also possible to form some groups of 1 girl + 2 boys and 2 groups with 2 boys, 1 girl and 1 group with 2 girls and 1 boy.

First, let's consider case 1 where there is 1 group of 2 girls and 1 boy, and 4 groups with 1 girl and 2 boys.
We choose 2 girls from 6: 6C2 = 15 ways.
We choose 1 boy from 9: 9C1 = 9 ways.
Now we have 4 girls left, we choose 1 group with 1 girl, and 2 boys, which are 4C1 and 8C2.
The number of arrangements will be like, (6C2 * 9C1) * (4C1 * 8C2) * (3C1 * 6C2) * (2C1 * 4C2) * (1C1 * 2C2)

Since these groups are indistinguishable, that is, when we group them, the order does not matter, consider two different combinations. Let's arrange it:
Groups 1: 2 girls and 1 boy.
Girls choose: 6C2. Boys choose: 9C1.

Then we have 4 girls, 8 boys remaining. We pick 1 girl and 2 boys.
Girls choose: 4C1. Boys choose: 8C2.
So it is (6C2*9C1) * (4C1*8C2) * (3C1*6C2) * (2C1*4C2) * (1*2C2) = (15*9) * (4*28) * (3*15) *(2*6) * 1 = (15*9) * (4*28)*(3*15)*(12)

Groups are identical. If we order the groups, then there are 5!. But because the order of the groups doesn't matter, we divide by 4!.
So it is 6C2 * 9C1 * 4C1 * 8C2 * 3C1 * 6C2 * 2C1 * 4C2 * 1C1 * 2C2 / 4!
Groups are indistinguishable. The groups of (2,1) or (1,2) or (0,3) are distinct arrangements when order is taken in consideration.
Instead, we can view it this way: pick 1 boy out of 9, choose 2 girls. 9C1 * 6C2. The remaining will form the 4 sets of 2 boys and 1 girl.
Pick the first two boys out of 8, and choose one girl. 8C2 * 4C1. Then 6C2 * 3C1. Then 4C2 * 2C1 and then 1 and 2C2. Then we divide by 4! to adjust the order.

Instead, let's think about this a bit differently. We can choose 1 boy, so pick 1 out of 9. Then we assign to one of the 5 groups. So first, 9 ways to choose a boy, and 6C2 = 15 ways. The total will be 9*15*

We can choose any of 9 boys to form a group of 2 boys, which gives us (9! / 2!7!) * (8!/2!6!) *... But since the grouping is indistinguishable, we must divide by 5! to get rid of the duplicate arrangement.
Consider forming groups of 2 boys and 1 girl = 45 * (8!)
The best way is to pick 1 girl, then pick the boys. The result should be 45 * 8! / 2

We calculate as follows:

* Choose a girl to be in a group. We have 6 options.
* Choose two boys to be with her. We have 9 choices for the first boy, and 8 for the second. Since order doesn't matter, divide by 2. Total ways = 6 * (9 * 8)/2 = 6 * 36 = 216
* Now, consider the remaining people. We pick one girl to be in the second set: We will have 5 choices. Choose 2 boys. This will give 7*6/2 = 21 ways.
The result will become 45*8! / 2 .

We can solve this way: consider the case of 45, and then arrange boys.

Divide by 2 as the order of groups doesn't matter.

Final Answer: The final answer is \(\frac{45}{2} (9!)\)
Was this answer helpful?
0

Top Questions on Permutations and Combinations