Step 1: Rule of thumb:
A simple structure with free hydrogen bonding groups and small hydrocarbon part dissolves best.
Step 2: Compare:
Phenol: one -OH, no extra groups. p-Cresol: extra $\text{CH}_3$, more hydrophobic. o-Nitrophenol: internal H-bond locks the OH. p-Nitrophenol: strongly associated through intermolecular H-bonds and a bulkier ring.
Step 3: Result:
Phenol is the most soluble of these four.
Final Answer:
Phenol is the most soluble, option (A).
\[ \boxed{\text{Phenol (A)}} \]