Step 1: Charge stays fixed.
After the battery is removed, no charge can flow in or out. So the charge $Q$ on the plates is constant.
Step 2: Voltage depends on capacitance.
The plate voltage is $V = \dfrac{Q}{C}$. If $C$ changes, $V$ must change since $Q$ is fixed.
Step 3: Pulling out the slab lowers $C$.
A dielectric raises capacitance, so removing it lowers $C$. As more slab comes out, $C$ keeps falling.
Step 4: So voltage rises.
Since $V = \dfrac{Q}{C}$ and $C$ goes down, $V$ goes up as the slab is pulled out.
Step 5: Find the shape of the rise.
Modelling the slab-out part and slab-in part as two parallel capacitors, $C(x)$ falls steadily with the pulled-out length $x$, so $V(x)$ climbs steadily from a non-zero start value.
Step 6: Match the graph.
The right graph shows voltage starting at a positive value and increasing with $x$. This matches option 1.
\[ \boxed{V \text{ increases as the dielectric is pulled out}} \]